CIRA, the .ca domain registrar, is proposing to allow a restricted subset of IDNs (Internationalized Domain Names) in order to support accented French characters in domain names.
If you speak or write in French, this will likely affect you at some point. If you use any .ca domain names, this may still affect you, although probably in less direct ways.
Speaking only on my own behalf (specifically: MUUG does not currently have an official position on the matter), I encourage anyone who cares about our national ccTLD to review the information CIRA has made available, form an opinion, and voice your opinion promptly.
IMHO, this is even more important than voting – if we choose poorly in an election, we have the opportunity to collectively change our minds in five years or less (usually four), whereas the CIRA IDN policy is likely to affect Canadians and Canada itself for decades to come. There’s no automatic reconsultation in four years, and there’s no built-in review process for decisions taken by NGOs like CIRA. In fact, once a decision like this is made, there may be no recourse at all if we collectively decide we don’t like the result.
It’s obvious to me that CIRA is expecting to make a tidy sum of money by doing this (otherwise I believe they would be taking a different direction altogether), which I believe is OK as long as the internet-using-public’s interests are still served. I already have an opinion on the matter, and I’ll be making a submission.
CIRA is effectively an NGO [I can’t tell what their legal status is right now], and they’re voluntarily doing the right thing by consulting the public – they’re not obligated to do so – but that consultation process is only effective if CIRA members express their opinions.
Please express your opinion.
-Adam Thompson
mailto:athompso@athompso.net athompso@athompso.net
From: CIRA / ACEI [mailto:communications.ca@cira.ca] Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 10:29 To: athompso@athompso.net Subject: CIRA consultation on accented domain names
Consultation on accented doman names http://www.cira.ca/assets/Images/mass-mail/CA-logo.jpg
Have your say: Join CIRA’s consultation on accented domain names
_____
Dear Adam Thompson,
As part of our effort to continually enhance the .CA domain, the Canadian Internet Registration Authority (CIRA) is considering the implementation of French character Internationalized Domain Names (IDNs) at the second level (to the left of the dot).
An Internationalized Domain Name is simply a domain name that contains characters other than a-z, 0-9 or hyphens.
CIRA is planning the addition of the following accented characters to .CA domain names:
* é, ë, ê, è * à, â * ô * ù, û, ü * ç * î, ï
This means you could soon see domain names like préside.ca, grâce.ca, etc. Before we can implement IDNs, CIRA is preparing a framework that will help us create a policy for launching accented domain names. As a Registrant, we are seeking your input on our proposed framework.
On September 20, 2011, CIRA opened a public consultation concerning our planned launch of IDNs. The feedback received from .CA holders like you, as well as our Members, Registrars and other stakeholders, will help us shape the final IDN launch policy. Learn more about the proposed policy and share your views at http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en www.idnconsultation.ca.
About CIRA The Canadian Internet Registration Authority is the Member-driven organization that manages Canada’s .CA domain name registry, develops and implements policies that support Canada’s Internet community, and represents the .CA registry internationally.
http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en/learn-about-it LEARN MORE ABOUT IDNs CIRA has developed a great interactive tool to map out all the basics about IDNs. http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en/learn-about-it View our great new IDN road map.
http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en/have-your-say HAVE YOUR SAY! Tell us what you think about our proposed IDN launch process. You can http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en/have-your-say/make-a-submission make a submission or http://www.idnconsultation.ca/community/en/have-your-say/discussions join the discussion.
http://www.cira.ca/assets/Images/mass-mail/member/bubble-left.jpg
Connect with CIRA
http://www.cira.ca/assets/Images/mass-mail/member/bubble-right.jpg
http://www.facebook.com/cira.ca?ref=ts
http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2456714
http://www.youtube.com/ciranews
http://www.slideshare.net/ciranews
_____
Email Information Please do not reply directly to this email. This email was sent from a notification-only address that cannot accept incoming email.
Inquiries regarding your .CA domain name should be directed to CIRA's Registration Support Department: Email: mailto:info@cira.ca info@cira.ca Telephone: 1-877-860-1411
Unsubscribe If you prefer not to receive future non-mandatory emails from CIRA, you may unsubscribe by sending an email to mailto:unsubscribe@cira.ca unsubscribe@cira.ca. Please allow 10 business days for processing. If you unsubscribe, CIRA will continue to send mandatory transactional messages related to your .CA domain name registration. If you are a .CA Member, you will also continue to receive mandatory messages related to your membership.
Please note that if you are currently using the privacy services of your Registrar, or have your Registrar listed as your Administrative Contact, you will not be able to unsubscribe through CIRA.
View CIRA's http://www.cira.ca/privacy/policy.html Privacy Policy.
© 2011 Canadian Internet Registration Authority. All rights reserved.
On 2011-09-22 Adam Thompson wrote:
CIRA, the .ca domain registrar, is proposing to allow a restricted subset of IDNs (Internationalized Domain Names) in order to support accented French characters in domain names.
(Another super late reply)
I read through a few pages of the end-user comments on the link provided and I am very happy to see that:
a) Canadians that bothered to comment appear extremely intelligent, intelligible, and sensible
and
b) it was virtually unanimous that accents were a bad idea or had to be implemented extremely carefully.
My big concern was making domain spoofing even easier, like registering [accented e]bay.ca and then stealing passwords. With the tiny size of fonts I use, I'd be screwed if I had to differentiate between the variations of e. Not to mention my IBM clicky keyboard has no accented chars and I have no idea whatsoever how to input them using alternate methods!
It will be interesting to see how this plays out now that the commenting is closed. Hopefully they'll listen to the excellent user contributions.
-
Adam Thompson -
Trevor Cordes