[RndTbl] dialog(1) shell fd acrobatics question

[Adam Thompson]

I’m trying to debug a shell script that uses dialog(1), which has the unfortunate habit of overwriting the debug output I wanted to see.
After quite some time banging my head against the wall, I grabbed the source to dialog to look at their examples.

Their examples follow a pattern I have NOT been following; I’m now looking at this trying to understand WTF it does:

1             exec 3>&1
2             returntext=`$DIALOG --title "RANGE BOX" --rangebox "Please set the volume..." 0 60 0 123 5 2>&1 1>&3`
3             returncode=$?
4             exec 3>&-

so… ok.
Line 1 duplicates FD 1 (stdout) into FD 3.  That’s usually so we can mess with FD 1 later on and still have a handle to stdout.  Good so far.
Line 2 runs /usr/bin/dialog in a subshell, the options to dialog(1) are irrelevant here.  I’m looking at the redirects.
    “2>&1” duplicates FD 1 into FD 2, effectively throwing away the handle to the inherited /dev/stderr and forcing stderr output onto stdout.  That’s a good thing because dialog(1) reports its results onto stderr by default to avoid messing with curses(3) output.
    “1>&3” however, throws away stdout (FD 1), replacing it with FD 3 which is… already a copy of FD 1 ???
Line 3 is obvious.
Line 4 closes FD 3.  Not sure that we need to bother, but OK, cleaning up behind ourselves is usually a good thing.

I get the need for swapping stdin/stderr, as dialog(1) – well, really curses(3) - uses stdout to paint the screen, so dialog(1) spits its results out on stderr to avoid conflicting.  If we’re in a subshell trying to capture that output, we need to grab it just as dialog(1) exits – and $() assignment only captures stdout.

But what’s the point of having FD 3 in this setup, if all we do is assign it to stdin inside the subshell and then forget about it?

Can anyone see what I’m missing here?
-Adam

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://muug.ca/pipermail/roundtable/attachments/20240705/edd370f3/attachment.htm>